12 Easy to Make Homemade Ice Cream Sandwiches

Heads up, Empowered Shoppers, we’re a participant in affiliate marketing programs. For more information, see our disclosure here.

Once you’ve made ice cream sandwiches at home, the store-bought versions seem so boring. The recipes are usually quite simple too. There are basically three ingredients: a type of ice cream, a type of cookie and something special to give it panache. You can substitute brownies or even doughnuts for the cookies, and frozen custard or yogurt for the ice cream. Here are 12 great recipe ideas to get started.

How to Make Homemade Ice Cream Sandwiches

1. Coffee Overload

Coffee ice cream + coffee-chocolate cookies + dark chocolate espresso beans.
– recipe via Becca Bakes

Coffee Overload Ice Cream Sandwiches

2. Brownie Double Mint

Mint ice cream + sliced brownies + Andes Creme De Menthe.
– recipe via Love Grows Wild

Brownie Double Mint Ice Cream Sandwiches

3. Valentine’s Day

Strawberry-cheesecake ice cream + heart-shaped chocolate cookies + a kiss.
– recipe via The Candid Appetite

Chocolate Strawberry Ice Cream Sandwiches

4. On a Stick

Cinnamon ice cream + oatmeal-raisin cookies + sticks.
– recipe via Babble

mini ice cream sandwich on a stick

5. Birthday Cake

Square-shaped ice cream sandwiches + rainbow sprinkles + birthday candle(s).
– recipe via All Things Simple

ice cream sandwich birthday cake
All Things Simple

6. Nutella Doughnuts

Coffee ice cream + sliced chocolate doughnuts + Nutella.
– recipe via How To: Simplify

Chocolate Doughnut, Nutella, and Coffee Ice Cream Sandwiches

7. Malted

Frozen custard + chocolate malt cookies + crushed malted milk balls.
– recipe via A Cozy Kitchen

malt ice cream sandwich

8. Honey Wafers

Honey-vanilla ice cream + butter wafers + fresh cherries.
– recipe via Delish

Honey-Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwiches

9. Chocolate Chip

Vanilla ice cream + chocolate chip cookies + chocolate chips.
– recipe via Martha Stewart

Mini Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwiches

10. Waffles

Any ice cream flavor + waffles + powdered sugar / whipped cream.
– recipe via Pass the Sushi

Waffle Ice Cream Sandwiches

11. Hot Fudge

Mint chocolate-chip ice cream + chocolate wafers + hot fudge sauce.
– recipe via Martha Stewart

Ice Cream Sandwiches With Hot Fudge Sauce

12. Baklava

Cinnamon ice cream + honey biscuits + crushed walnuts, cinnamon & brown sugar.
– recipe via Souvlaki for the Soul

baklava ice cream sandwich

Do these ice cream sandwiches have you mouth watering as much as mine? Which one do you want to try first? Let me know in the comments below!

You might also like: